Who Sells Roscoe Village: The Agents Behind 31 Sales in 12 Months

Roscoe Village is a north side Chicago neighborhood where single-family homes trade steadily, and across every Compass agent in the metro it produced 31 sales worth $53.6M over the last 12 months. The volume is spread thin among many names, which makes the ranking below useful: it shows which agents actually closed on these streets rather than which ones advertise here. The numbers that follow describe a market with a firm floor and a clear ceiling.  An average of $1.72M with a narrow band from $1,052,341 to $2,750,000 says Roscoe Village is a consistent market rather than a volatile one. At $490 per square foot, the price tracks size closely, which fits a neighborhood of similar-sized brick homes on standard lots. For a seller, the tight range means pricing is predictable against recent comparables; for a buyer, it means the spread between a modest and a premium home on the same block is smaller than in neighborhoods with mixed lot sizes. ## The leaders  1. **The Sheahan Group** — 4 sales totaling $9.6M, top sale $2,750,000 2. **Tim Sheahan** — 4 sales totaling $9.6M, top sale $2,750,000 3. **[Hayley Westhoff](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/hayley-westhoff)** — 4 sales totaling $7.7M, top sale $2,750,000 4. **Bridget Carey** — 3 sales totaling $6.8M, top sale $2,495,000 5. **Kathleen Malone** — 3 sales totaling $4.6M, top sale $1,800,000 6. **[Malone Residential](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/malone-residential)** — 3 sales totaling $4.6M, top sale $1,800,000 The top of the ranking is crowded. The Sheahan Group, Tim Sheahan and Hayley Westhoff each closed 4 sales, though the first two share the same $9.6M total and top price, suggesting overlapping listings. Bridget Carey, Kathleen Malone and Malone Residential follow with 3 sales each. With six agents ranked and the top three tied on count, the field is competitive rather than dominated by one name. A seller has several recent comparables to choose from among these leaders. ## The biggest Roscoe Village sales of the year  1. **3525 North Bell Avenue** — $2,750,000, closed June 2026, 6 bed, 6 bath, 5,000 sq ft · Brendan O'Malley 2. **3530 North Bell Avenue** — $2,750,000, closed March 2026, 6 bed, 6 bath · Lothamer Group 3. **1912 West School Street** — $2,495,000, closed April 2026, 6 bed, 6 bath, 4,000 sq ft · Bridget Carey The three biggest sales are all large, six-bedroom homes, and two hit the same $2,750,000 mark. 3525 North Bell Avenue closed at $2,750,000 in June 2026 through Brendan O'Malley, and 3530 North Bell Avenue closed at the same price in March 2026 through the Lothamer Group. 1912 West School Street brought $2,495,000 in April 2026 with Bridget Carey. All three are substantial family homes, which is where Roscoe Village prices peak. Hayley Westhoff and Malone Residential are on the directory, with pages carrying their current listings, contact details and open houses. A buyer can move from this ranking to what they have on the market now; a seller can use the record above, drawn from Compass transaction histories, to see which agents have closed on these streets recently. The list is a starting point for a conversation, not a final verdict. *Source: the Compass transaction histories of every Compass agent in the Chicago area, as recorded on September 16, 2026; closed sales in Roscoe Village over the 12 months to August 2026. One sale is one listing; a team and its members each count a shared sale.*