Who Sells Belmont-Hillsboro: The Agents Behind 11 Sales in 12 Months

Belmont-Hillsboro recorded 11 sales across every Compass agent in the Nashville area in the 12 months to August 2026. The average sale was $3.58M, about $608 per square foot, and prices ran from $2,000,000 to $5,064,050.  With a floor of $2,000,000 and a ceiling of $5,064,050, Belmont-Hillsboro operates exclusively in the luxury tier. The $3.58M average and $608 per square foot indicate that buyers pay a premium for location and lot size rather than just square footage. The narrow range suggests a consistent market where homes are priced based on comparable sales within the neighborhood itself, leaving little room for outliers. Sellers should expect a high baseline, while buyers will find no entry-level options. ## The leaders  1. **[Patricia Straus](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/patricia-straus)** — 3 sales totaling $9.3M, top sale $5,064,050 2. **[David Binkley](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/david-binkley)** — 2 sales totaling $8.4M, top sale $4,350,000 3. **[Caroline Smith](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/caroline-smith)** — 2 sales totaling $7.7M, top sale $4,800,000 4. **Sabrina Schulhauser** — 1 sale totaling $4.8M, top sale $4,775,000 5. **Katie Hewson** — 1 sale totaling $4.5M, top sale $4,475,000 6. **The Miles Team** — 1 sale totaling $4.5M, top sale $4,475,000 The leadership is concentrated but competitive. Patricia Straus led with 3 sales and $9.3M, including the year’s highest price. David Binkley and Caroline Smith each closed 2 sales, bringing $8.4M and $7.7M respectively. The remaining three agents closed one sale each. This distribution shows that while one agent has the most volume, the top tier is closely packed, with the top three agents handling seven of the eleven sales. Experience in this neighborhood is shared among a few key players. ## The biggest Belmont-Hillsboro sales of the year  1. **1708 Sweetbriar Avenue** — $5,064,050, closed December 2025, 6 bed, 8 bath, 6,453 sq ft · [Patricia Straus](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/patricia-straus) 2. **2509 Oakland Avenue** — $4,800,000, closed July 2026, 5 bed, 5 bath, 7,000 sq ft · [Caroline Smith](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/caroline-smith) 3. **1812 Sweetbriar Avenue** — $4,775,000, closed August 2026, 5 bed, 9 bath, 7,625 sq ft · Sabrina Schulhauser The top three sales were all substantial homes sold in late 2025 and mid-2026. 1708 Sweetbriar Avenue, sold by Patricia Straus for $5,064,050 in December 2025, was the highest-priced home at 6,453 square feet. 2509 Oakland Avenue, handled by Caroline Smith, closed at $4,800,000 in July 2026, and 1812 Sweetbriar Avenue, sold by Sabrina Schulhauser, brought $4,775,000 in August 2026. These homes share a profile of large, well-appointed residences in the neighborhood’s most desirable streets. *Source: the Compass transaction histories of every Compass agent in the Nashville area, as recorded on September 17, 2026; closed sales in Belmont-Hillsboro over the 12 months to August 2026. One sale is one listing; a team and its members each count a shared sale.*