Tarrytown Price Guide: What Homes Sold For in the Last 12 Months

Sixteen sales, $38.9M in volume, and a range from $595,000 to $8,500,000: that is Tarrytown over the last 12 months, counted across the agents in the Summer 2026 issue. The neighborhood’s character shows in the spread, with most trades in the middle and a few outliers at each end. The sections below break down the median, the price bands, and the agents who closed the most homes here.  The average of $2.43M is significantly higher than the median of $1.66M, which indicates that a small number of high-priced sales are skewing the mean upward. At $786 per square foot, Tarrytown commands a premium that exceeds many other Austin neighborhoods, driven by lot size and location rather than just home size. The range from $595,000 to $8,500,000 is extreme for one area, suggesting that condition and land value vary drastically. Sellers should look closely at the median to understand the typical trade, while buyers should be aware that the average is inflated by the top-tier estates. ## Where the sales fall Under $1M: 2, $1M to $2M: 8, $2M to $4M: 4 and $4M and up: 2.  Eight of the 16 sales fell between $1M and $2M, making that the neighborhood’s trading heart. Four homes sold between $2M and $4M, while two each landed under $1M and above $4M. This distribution shows that while Tarrytown has luxury estates, the bulk of activity happens in the mid-range, where buyers can access the location without the eight-figure price tag. For a seller, pricing into the $1M to $2M band aligns with the highest volume of recent transactions, whereas the $4M and up segment is a thin market with fewer recent comparables. ## The biggest Tarrytown sales  ## The latest closings 1. **3500 Enfield Road** — $595,000, closed August 2026, 2 bed, 2 bath, 1,520 sq ft · [Keenan Group](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/keenan-group) 2. **3407 Timberwood Circle** — $6,500,000, closed August 2026, 4 bed, 5 bath, 4,744 sq ft · [Stephanie Panozzo](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/stephanie-panozzo) 3. **2802 Warren Street** — $889,000, closed June 2026, 3 bed, 3 bath, 1,800 sq ft · [Alan Holt](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/alan-holt) ## Who sells Tarrytown  1. **[Nicole Kessler Group](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/nicole-kessler-group)** — 2 sales totaling $10.8M, top sale $8,500,000 2. **[Stephanie Panozzo](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/stephanie-panozzo)** — 2 sales totaling $8.5M, top sale $6,500,000 3. **[Mike Mogavero](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/mike-mogavero)** — 2 sales totaling $4.1M, top sale $2,469,000 Three agents lead the list with two sales each, but their volume differs widely. The Nicole Kessler Group closed $10.8M, including the $8.5M top sale, while Stephanie Panozzo closed $8.5M and Mike Mogavero closed $4.1M. This shows that while several agents are active, the leaders handle the largest properties. For a seller with a high-end estate, the Nicole Kessler Group and Stephanie Panozzo have the most recent experience with eight-figure and seven-figure closings. Mike Mogavero’s record suggests a strength in the mid-to-upper range, providing a different profile for those selling smaller or renovated homes. The directory pages for the Nicole Kessler Group, Stephanie Panozzo, and Mike Mogavero offer current listings, contact details, and open house schedules. These pages connect the historical data in this guide to the active market, allowing buyers to see what is available now and sellers to review the agents’ current portfolios. The guide serves as a reference for pricing strategy, while the directory provides the direct link to the agents who have recently closed in the neighborhood. *Source: Compass transaction histories of the agents in the Summer 2026 issue, as recorded on September 10, 2026; closed sales in Tarrytown over the 12 months to September 2026. Figures cover those agents' sales only, not every sale in the neighborhood.*