Who Sells Cherry Creek: The Agents Behind 20 Sales in 12 Months

Twenty sales and $58.7M in Cherry Creek over the last 12 months define the scale of activity for Compass agents in this neighborhood. The average price of $2.93M places every closing firmly in the luxury tier, with no entry below $1,510,000. The data below identifies the agents behind these transactions, offering a clear view of who is driving sales in one of Denver's most distinct markets.  The $735 per square foot figure highlights the premium attached to Cherry Creek properties, where the $2.93M average is supported by a floor of $1,510,000. This narrow, high band means that even the lowest sales command significant sums, reflecting the area's consistent desirability. For buyers, the spread up to $5,176,880 shows the ceiling for the most expansive or renovated homes, while the average serves as a reliable benchmark for typical transactions. ## The leaders  1. **McKinley Group** — 4 sales totaling $11.8M, top sale $4,450,000 2. **Josh Mckinley** — 3 sales totaling $10.1M, top sale $4,450,000 3. **Kristen Crabtree** — 2 sales totaling $7.5M, top sale $3,750,000 4. **Scott Kirkegaard** — 2 sales totaling $7.5M, top sale $3,750,000 5. **Coleen Sanders** — 2 sales totaling $5.6M, top sale $3,050,000 6. **Terri Barnes** — 1 sale totaling $5.2M, top sale $5,176,880 The McKinley Group leads with 4 sales totaling $11.8M, followed closely by Josh Mckinley with 3 sales for $10.1M. Kristen Crabtree, Scott Kirkegaard, and Coleen Sanders each closed 2 sales, while Terri Barnes secured the single highest transaction at $5,176,880. The field is competitive, with the top two entities accounting for a significant portion of the volume, yet several other agents contribute meaningfully to the neighborhood's activity. ## The biggest Cherry Creek sales of the year 1. **444 Saint Paul Street** — $5,176,880, closed August 2026, 4 bed, 6 bath, 10,111 sq ft · Terri Barnes 2. **450 Steele Street** — $4,975,000, closed September 2025, 4 bed, 5 bath, 6,599 sq ft · William Graves 3. **203 Garfield Street** — $4,450,000, closed May 2026, 4 bed, 5 bath, 4,949 sq ft · Nicole Keiller Although none of the ranked agents are currently listed on the directory, the data provides a clear record of recent performance. Buyers and sellers can use this ranking to identify professionals with active Cherry Creek experience. The directory page remains a resource for listings, contact details, and open houses for other agents, offering a broader view of the market's current offerings. *Source: the Compass transaction histories of every Compass agent in the Denver area, as recorded on September 21, 2026; closed sales in Cherry Creek over the 12 months to August 2026. One sale is one listing; a team and its members each count a shared sale.*