Who Sells Preserve: The Agents Behind 15 Sales in 12 Months

Preserve is a master-planned community in north Denver where large new-build homes trade at high prices, and across every Compass agent in the metro it produced 15 sales worth $44.9M over the last 12 months. That is a small number of closings for a neighborhood of this size, which means the ranking below is built on a focused set of transactions rather than a high-volume market. The agents who appear here are the ones with recent closings on Preserve streets.  The spread from $1,850,000 to $3,700,000 is modest for a luxury market, and the $456 per square foot average explains why: these are large, newer homes on comparable lots. The $2.99M average is not pulled by outliers but reflects a consistent market where most sales fall within a few hundred thousand dollars of each other. Sellers should expect pricing to be driven by square footage and lot position rather than by condition or renovation. ## The leaders  1. **[Mitch Lazar](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/mitch-lazar)** — 5 sales totaling $15.5M, top sale $3,700,000 2. **Lindsey Reichwald** — 2 sales totaling $6.4M, top sale $3,550,000 3. **The Ivy Collective** — 2 sales totaling $6.4M, top sale $3,550,000 4. **Carla Bartell** — 1 sale totaling $3.7M, top sale $3,700,000 5. **[Lisa Taylor](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/lisa-taylor)** — 1 sale totaling $3.6M, top sale $3,600,000 6. **[Nick Crothers](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/nick-crothers)** — 1 sale totaling $3.6M, top sale $3,600,000 The ranking is top-heavy. Mitch Lazar's 5 sales are more than double the next two agents' 2 each, and his $15.5M volume is more than double theirs. The Ivy Collective and Lindsey Reichwald are tied at 2 sales and $6.4M, and four agents closed one sale apiece. For a seller, the leader has the most recent comparables to draw on, while the others offer less recent evidence of work in this specific neighborhood. ## The biggest Preserve sales of the year 1. **5691 South Elm Street** — $3,700,000, closed August 2026, 6 bed, 7 bath, 9,009 sq ft · [Mitch Lazar](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/mitch-lazar) 2. **4651 Preserve Parkway North** — $3,700,000, closed January 2026, 5 bed, 8 bath, 7,291 sq ft · Carla Bartell 3. **4340 Preserve Parkway North** — $3,600,000, closed February 2026, 4 bed, 7 bath, 7,657 sq ft · [Lisa Taylor](https://directory.luxuryhomesshowcase.com/listings/lisa-taylor) At the top of the year, 5691 South Elm Street set the pace at $3,700,000 in August 2026, a six-bedroom, 9,009-square-foot home sold by Mitch Lazar. Two other homes closed at the same price or close to it: 4651 Preserve Parkway North at $3,700,000 in January 2026 through Carla Bartell, and 4340 Preserve Parkway North at $3,600,000 in February 2026 through Lisa Taylor. All three are large, newer homes with multiple baths, the standard for the upper end of this neighborhood. Mitch Lazar, Lisa Taylor and Nick Crothers are on the directory, and their pages carry current listings, contact details and the open houses they are hosting. For a buyer, that is the shortest route from a neighborhood they like to the agents who know it. For a seller in Preserve, the ranking above is a record of recent closings by name, which is a better basis for a conversation than a yard sign count. *Source: the Compass transaction histories of every Compass agent in the Denver area, as recorded on September 18, 2026; closed sales in Preserve over the 12 months to August 2026. One sale is one listing; a team and its members each count a shared sale.*